TV/Movies Megathread

[garbon]

Finished re-watching Battlestar Galactica. Ending was still dreadful. I think one of the biggest issues was that the 2nd half of the final episode (I guess Daybreak Pt III) was entirely superfluous.  When your series finale wraps up with multiple jumps to events taking place before the start of the series (the characters lives when Zak Adama was alive and when Roslin slept with one of her former students), you know you are in for trouble.

Perhaps similar to how Lost ended without satisfactorily explaining most of the mysteries in the series, though I don't know as I gave up on Lost early on.

[Habbaku]

Perhaps similar to how Lost ended without satisfactorily explaining most of the mysteries in the series, though I don't know as I gave up on Lost early on.

Lucky SOB.

[Eddie Teach]

The 100,000 year time table was pretty ridiculous. Even assuming Adama managed to snuff out all high tech knowledge among the survivors, at the very least people would start planting crops.


Lost was ok. The mysteries were a bust but the character dramas were still more compelling than most shows.

[garbon]

The 100,000 year time table was pretty ridiculous. Even assuming Adama managed to snuff out all high tech knowledge among the survivors, at the very least people would start planting crops.

Presumably they mostly just starved to death, what with most of them not being equipped for pastoral life.

[Josquius]

That does seem logical given the fire the ships into the sun crap.
I'd like to pretend though that something bad happened hundreds of years later that destroyed their civilization.

[The Brain]

Started watching Band of Brothers. Schwimmer, nooooo!!!

That was my first reaction when I first saw the show.  But keeping watching it gets much better.

Maybe the Brain actually feels bad for Schwimmer's character? 

[garbon]

That does seem logical given the fire the ships into the sun crap.
I'd like to pretend though that something bad happened hundreds of years later that destroyed their civilization.

Maybe the remaining humanoid cylons (unless we are to believe all of Cavil's forces were on the colony - which clearly they were not as there weren't the remaining base ships about) attacked later. Or the centurion ones attacked.

[Viking]

The 100,000 year time table was pretty ridiculous. Even assuming Adama managed to snuff out all high tech knowledge among the survivors, at the very least people would start planting crops.


Lost was ok. The mysteries were a bust but the character dramas were still more compelling than most shows.

meh, immediately after adama gets rid of tech, Toba happens.

[Darth Wagtaros]

The 100,000 year time table was pretty ridiculous. Even assuming Adama managed to snuff out all high tech knowledge among the survivors, at the very least people would start planting crops.

Presumably they mostly just starved to death, what with most of them not being equipped for pastoral life.

It's about the characters!

[dps]

Finished re-watching Battlestar Galactica. Ending was still dreadful. I think one of the biggest issues was that the 2nd half of the final episode (I guess Daybreak Pt III) was entirely superfluous.  When your series finale wraps up with multiple jumps to events taking place before the start of the series (the characters lives when Zak Adama was alive and when Roslin slept with one of her former students), you know you are in for trouble.

Perhaps similar to how Lost ended without satisfactorily explaining most of the mysteries in the series, though I don't know as I gave up on Lost early on.

That's a problem with shows that have overall story arcs--they almost never wrap things up in a reasonably satisfactory manner.  Only exceptions I can think of offhand are Babylon 5 and The Fugitive.  Well, maybe The Prisoner--you can't really say the finale explained everything, but given the surreal nature of the show, that was appropriate IMO.

[Syt]

Finished re-watching Battlestar Galactica. Ending was still dreadful. I think one of the biggest issues was that the 2nd half of the final episode (I guess Daybreak Pt III) was entirely superfluous.  When your series finale wraps up with multiple jumps to events taking place before the start of the series (the characters lives when Zak Adama was alive and when Roslin slept with one of her former students), you know you are in for trouble.

Perhaps similar to how Lost ended without satisfactorily explaining most of the mysteries in the series, though I don't know as I gave up on Lost early on.

That's a problem with shows that have overall story arcs--they almost never wrap things up in a reasonably satisfactory manner.  Only exceptions I can think of offhand are Babylon 5 and The Fugitive.  Well, maybe The Prisoner--you can't really say the finale explained everything, but given the surreal nature of the show, that was appropriate IMO.

DS9, too. Well, if you can buy into Sisko's "Ascension".

[Viking]

Finished re-watching Battlestar Galactica. Ending was still dreadful. I think one of the biggest issues was that the 2nd half of the final episode (I guess Daybreak Pt III) was entirely superfluous.  When your series finale wraps up with multiple jumps to events taking place before the start of the series (the characters lives when Zak Adama was alive and when Roslin slept with one of her former students), you know you are in for trouble.

Perhaps similar to how Lost ended without satisfactorily explaining most of the mysteries in the series, though I don't know as I gave up on Lost early on.

That's a problem with shows that have overall story arcs--they almost never wrap things up in a reasonably satisfactory manner.  Only exceptions I can think of offhand are Babylon 5 and The Fugitive.  Well, maybe The Prisoner--you can't really say the finale explained everything, but given the surreal nature of the show, that was appropriate IMO.

Even B5 went through the omg we're cancelled rush during season 4 so they finished off the story arc and then they got a season 5 and they stretched the entire good-by episode into a full season. They also compressed the remainder of the final season into a single episode at the end of season 4. All in all it made for a fast paced action packed season 4 and then a drawn out rather boring season 5 with a touching final episode in which all the groundwork had been properly laid.

[frunk]

I thought the second half of season 5 picked up a bit particularly with the G'Kar/Mollari storyline, but the first half was dreadful.

[Syt]

I thought the second half of season 5 picked up a bit particularly with the G'Kar/Mollari storyline, but the first half was dreadful.

REMEMBER BYRON!

[Viking]

I thought the second half of season 5 picked up a bit particularly with the G'Kar/Mollari storyline, but the first half was dreadful.

JMS was probably thinking, hey with no plot to advance, why not make use of these two fantastic actors and the fantastic characters he created for them.