Brexit and the waning days of the United Kingdom

Started by Josquius, February 20, 2016, 07:46:34 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

How would you vote on Britain remaining in the EU?

British- Remain
12 (12%)
British - Leave
7 (7%)
Other European - Remain
21 (21%)
Other European - Leave
6 (6%)
ROTW - Remain
34 (34%)
ROTW - Leave
20 (20%)

Total Members Voted: 98

Richard Hakluyt

I think it is fair to say that the leave is a more disparate coalition than the remainers. Remainers mainly vary in the degree of enthusiasm for the EU, all the way from tepid to quite warm; meanwhile brexiters include a wide variety of political views, from racists who hate the EU because of the foreigners to people who dislike it because of its protectionist ways.

Sheilbh

Yep. As you say everyone from the bigots, through Anglo-Gaullists and Bennites to hard-core Greens and Trots at the other end. Truly a rainbow coalition.
Let's bomb Russia!

Duque de Bragança

Anglo-Gaullists?  :lol:

I know sovereignist is not commonly used in the UK but mixing de Gaulle with UK sovereignism is just wrong.

Sheilbh

And inaccurate. They're a lot less in love with the future than the General :(
Let's bomb Russia!

Sheilbh

Interesting/canny appointment by Juncker as this is one areas both sides will definitely want to keep the closest relationship possible:
QuoteJuncker makes UK Commissioner Julian King EU's anti-terror tsar
British commissioner will set EU strategy in wake of Europe's escalating terror threat.
By   FLORIAN EDER 8/2/16, 9:07 AM CET Updated 8/2/16, 12:19 PM CET

European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker will make the British nominee for the Commission, Julian King, Europe's new anti-terrorism tsar, the Commission announced Tuesday.

The decision to name King the commissioner for the security union was made after Juncker "meditated" on what role to assign Britain's incoming member of the EU executive body, Commission Spokesperson Mina Andreeva told reporters yesterday.

The commissioner for the security union will support the implementation of the European Agenda on Security, which the European Commission adopted in April 2015, according to a "mission letter" sent to King.


King's new role reflects the Commission president's priorities in the post-Brexit Commission, and demonstrates his signature sense of humor.

After the Brussels attacks in March 2016, Juncker called for a "security union" to respond to the threat of terrorism and said Europe needed to better coordinate its response.

"We feel we need capital markets union, energy union, economic and monetary union, but we also think that we need a security union," Juncker said on March 23.


David Cameron had reportedly requested an environment portfolio for King, but that was never a real option

While many EU countries applauded the move, the U.K. was a notable exception. The job in security policy will be seen by many across the Continent as politically important, but with a raison d'être that was widely criticized in Britain.

Juncker informed both Julian King and U.K. Prime Minister Theresa May Monday evening of his decision, according to EU officials.

The Brussels bubble has been abuzz with speculation on what job Juncker would give King, given he represents the first country ever to leave the EU. POLITICO reported in July that other commissioners had been asked to cede parts of their portfolios to King.

Sources said Martin Selmayr, chief of staff to President Jean-Claude Juncker, has approached at least three commissioners, like Miguel Arias Cañete (pictured), whose portfolio covers climate action and energy

Former British Prime Minister David Cameron had reportedly, according to POLITICO, requested an environment portfolio for King, but that was never a real option, EU officials told POLITICO.

Cameron's request was knocked back because the environment portfolio would have had too significant a conflict of interests for a United Kingdom set to quit the EU, such as deciding how to share the burden of joint EU 2030 climate goals among EU countries, an issue that will have to be negotiated in the years to come.

Further, giving King the environment portfolio would have meant having to take it away from a Socialist commissioner, harming a fragile political balance within the Commission, according to EU officials.

The decision to give King the security portfolio was also made to ensure the incoming commissioner is kept busy.

"There's many important things we have to tackle, and the British member of the Commission should take an active part in this," a source familiar with Juncker's thinking told POLITICO. Read: The British Commissioner should have important work and travel commitments, rather than sit idly by with time to filter sensitive information to the British government during Brexit negotiations with the EU.

A spokesperson for the U.K. government said in a statement Tuesday that it welcomed Juncker's decision. "The U.K. will continue to fulfill our rights and obligations as a member state until we leave the EU and the prime minister has been clear that we will be an active player so it is right that we should continue to have a commissioner role.

"Security is a vital issue for all member states and co-operation across the EU can help to better protect us all from the range of threats we face."


This article has been updated to include the statement from the U.K. government.

Also discovered why everyone was going mad about passports:
Let's bomb Russia!

Sheilbh

Oh and by the way the UKIP leadership election is exactly what you'd expect:
QuoteKnow your Ukip leadership candidate
Ian Dunt By Ian Dunt
Tuesday, 2 August 2016 10:48 AM

The Ukip leadership election is underway, although we still don't really know how many people are in it. Diane James might still throw her hat in the ring. And front-runner Steven Woolfe failed to get his application in on time, apparently due to IT problems at Ukip head office. There's now some protracted decision-making process by which they decide if he's still eligible. This being Ukip, the protracted decision-making process is accompanied by fierce counter-briefings.

Assuming Woolfe makes it onto the final list, he'll find himself up against some intriguing and often rather odd opposition.

Elizabeth Jones

Jones' most famous moment came a couple of years back during a seemingly innocuous discussion on Voice of Africa radio. In the middle of a debate with Helen Pattison of the Socialist Party, the Ukip Lambeth deputy chairman apocalyptically lost her cool (13:40 in on the clip below).

"Will you just shut up?" she suddenly screams.

There's a moment of stunned silence before Pattison whispers: "Oh God." Someone else meekly says: "This is an intellectual discussion."

Jones replies: "I've just had enough. Since 2010, I've had the left wing shouting and shouting and shouting at me and I'm not going to tolerate anymore." Then she puts on a voice like she's doing the voice-over for an action movie. "It ends now."


This colourful personality is also on show on Jones' Twitter feed. There are, as on all Ukip Twitter accounts, attacks on BBC bias. But Jones takes it further in retweeting criticism of the BBC journalists who just interviewed her.
QuoteFollow
Louis Kasatkin @louiskasatkin
@joneselizab Well handled interview @bbc5live.Junior wannabe cutting edge presenters trawling for controversy as alternative to real news.
7:57 AM - 2 Aug 2016
  2 2 Retweets   1 1 like

There are also retweets for anyone who says she's attractive.
Quote8h
LizJones4UKIPLeader @joneselizab
@freedomlynn123 Thanks Lynn x
Follow
Lynn Smith @freedomlynn123
@joneselizab You are very welcome although I still want Steven how about you as deputy? The best looking leader and deputy probably ever!
10:43 AM - 2 Aug 2016
  1 1 Retweet   1 1 like
QuoteFollow
Samuel @50degreesam
Stephen Woolfe easily has the best chance to be #UKIP leader but I'd still back Liz Jones as the only candidate who's really hot
5:26 PM - 28 Jul 2016
  2 2 Retweets   2 2 likes

There's one short video of her launching her campaign on YouTube, in which she promises more internal democracy in the party. Most of the candidates allude to this and I'm taking it as code for score-settling with internal rivals after the election. She also uses the video to claim that Nigel Farage has an "inherent" understanding for refugees "in his own blood" because he is descended from Huguenots. She really says that.

Policy-wise, there's not much around. She mentions universal broadband in the video and says she doesn't want to "rewrite the Bible" when it comes to Ukip's 2015 manifesto.

The articles she tweets are predominantly from the Daily Express. One concerns skipping Article 50 and leaving the EU by repealing 1972 European Communities Act. This might be quicker than Article 50, but it would mean Britain's word in signing treaties could no longer be trusted. We'd be an international pariah. She is also very keen on Theresa May prioritising trade deals outside the EU before those with the EU, even though major non-EU economies have already said they need to see a resolution to the UK's European relationship before they can enter talks.

Jonathan Arnott

Arnott is Ukip's North East England MEP. He's a bit of an unknown quantity and reading his campaign literature doesn't really help matters. Posts on subjects like the economy, crime and education don't have any policies and are mostly filled with centre-right platitudes about the effectiveness of the free market.

He's particularly concerned that "those who torture defenceless animals to death should be jailed". There are already laws for this.

He calls for "constitutional reform that will achieve a dynamic, democratic party", although again it's unclear whether this is a concrete system or just a plan to settle scores with Ukip rivals. Where you can find policies, they're pretty vanilla. He thinks HS2 is currently "poor value for money", he wants to make "prison conditions tougher", protect girls from female genital mutilation, be tougher on rape, introduce an initial presumption of shared (50-50) parenting in custody cases and hold referendums on more "key social issues".

But his views on Brexit negotiations are unsurprisingly more robust. He's clearly uncomfortable with Theresa May, saying that since Andrea Leadsom stepped down "the establishment is organising itself for 'business as usual'."

"We need a tough negotiator," he said in a blogpost. "We need someone who will understand some fundamental principles of negotiation. Let's talk about how I buy a car."

There follows a protracted metaphor about the sensible way to approach trade negotiations based on his experiences of buying automobiles.

"Firstly, I don't take someone with me who's going to tell me that the car is worth the asking price and I'll never get a better deal. If I'm trying to haggle down the price, having a friend there telling me not to haggle is going to cost me a lot of money.

"Ultimately if I go to buy a car, and the dealership isn't playing ball, I have to be willing to walk out of the door. As I leave, they always call me back and suddenly find that they can offer me a better deal."

What can you learn from this painful exercise in comparison? Firstly, that he does not approve of Remainers being in charge of delivering the Brexit deal. And secondly, that the UK should be prepared to drop out the single market and into WTO rules. Funnily enough, this is actually one of the more moderate Ukip approaches to Brexit. Unlike Woolfe, he hasn't pledged to leave the single market. Unlike Jones, he doesn't want to just repeal the 72 Act. Hapless metaphors aside, Arnott evidently believes in trying to reach a deal first.


Bill Etheridge

Etheridge is gloriously awful. Evidence A: his campaign slogan is 'Billieve in Bill'. His crowdsourcing appeal has currently raised £8.

The West Midlands MEP wants to suspend all visits for the first six months of a prisoner's sentence, as well as any freedom to leave the cell. He would also charge prisoners £40,000 a year until their funds are depleted. He wants to ban all electronics in jails, although quite why is not clear. As you might have guessed, he admits to having never visited a prison.

He also wants a referendum on the return of hanging, in which he will campaign in favour, saying: "The very worst crimes deserved the ultimate penalty".

It has not always been plain sailing for Etheridge. He came a cropper when the Daily Mail reported that he encouraged Ukip candidates to emulate Hitler's speaking style in 2014.

"Look back to the most magnetic and forceful public speaker possibly in history. When Hitler gave speeches, and many of the famous ones were at rallies, at the start he walks, back and forth, looked at people – there was a silence, he waited minutes just looking out at people, fixing them with his gaze."

Later, a member of the audience asked Etheridge how to use social media for campaigning. He replied, seemingly without a hint of irony:

"If you think for even a second that what you say can be screwed, twisted and spun, do not allow that video to be posted by people."

The MEP is only in the party following a departure from the Tories during disciplinary proceedings. He'd been suspended after posing in a photo with a golliwog doll. Shortly afterwards he wrote a book titled: A Post-Political Correctness Society. In it, he argued:

"The political and social elite have cravenly surrendered to the diktat of the Politically Correct dogma that has crushed free speech, smashed enterprise and reduced Britain to a mere shadow of its former self."

So, yeah. £8 doesn't seem that bad.

Lisa Duffy

Even on a list of people with very few policies, Duffy stands out by the lack of substance. She wants to start "tackling taboo subjects like integration" - seemingly unaware of the fact that immigration was the dominant theme of the referendum campaign. She wants "a positive modernised vision for British Islam", although it's not certain that her understanding of the religion would stretch far enough for her to be able to describe it.

Her Twitter feed is surprisingly apolitical, with room being devoted to her ranking on WordBrain. There are also typical tweets on the BBC's anti-Ukip propaganda and support for a petition for "European Union flags, emblems and logos be removed from all public buildings".

There's nothing else really.

Steven Woolfe

If Woolfe makes it onto the final candidates list, he'll be considered the instant front runner. You can see why - from the quality of his launch video, to the extensive interviews with respected media outlets. And there are actually a few interesting things about him.

He sounds like a mainstream politician, not a head banger - focusing on non-EU, non-immigration issues like social mobility. He has a backstory, rising from a council estate to the Bar. He uses awful Westminster phrases no normal person would ever dream of uttering, like 'British dream'. He does the standard mainstream politician bit about left and right not existing anymore, although admittedly he does it in a particularly painful metaphor ("I no longer believe in the right/left divide anymore. It's something of the past. It's a bit like Motorola – I want to be the Samsung and Apple of the future.")

Behind all that, there is the start of a strategy. Woolfe says "staying in the single market is not an option" and plainly plans to set himself up as Real Brexit should Theresa May try to do so in a bid to limit economic damage to the UK. Woolfe is also clearly thinking about how to link industrial northern Leave voters with the shires.

But his record is patchy enough to take the shine off his mainstream credibility. Aside from the late application, there is speculation that he might have forgotten to renew his membership, making him ineligible for the leadership. He's also admitted to Huffington Post that he failed to disclose a drink-driving ban when seeking election as a police and crime commissioner - a possible breach of electoral law. For a candidate running on competency and professionalism, it's not a good look. But given his competition, it's not necessarily one which would defeat him. Assuming his enemies in Ukip don't try to keep him off the ballot, that is.

Ian Dunt is the editor of Politics.co.uk/quote]

I believe Woolfe has now been disqualified (for the late forms, not the lying about his drink driving record). Article with clips and proper tweets in all their glory here:
http://www.politics.co.uk/blogs/2016/08/02/know-your-ukip-leadership-candidate
Let's bomb Russia!

Zanza

Security seems to be the perfect portfolio for a British commissioner. Britain will still participate in some way in the European security cooperation even after a Brexit and their policy goals there should coincide with those of the other European countries.

Sheilbh

In evergreen news: UKIP in chaos :lol:
Let's bomb Russia!

Agelastus

Quote from: Sheilbh on August 03, 2016, 07:07:24 AM
In evergreen news: UKIP in chaos :lol:

Well, what do you expect? They've apparently won their official "raison d'etre" so infighting seems less of a problem to the participants and this is the first leadership election they've had where most contestants actually hold political offices(Euro MPs and the like) rather than being mainly individuals of basically independent means (as minor political parties tend to be moneysinks.) And they don't have a history of "we're a broad church, buckle down and get on with it" to fall back on compared to the Tories and Labour; hence the "we're in a huff, we'll resign" actions of today.

They're just not used to this.

Which does beg the question of what Labour's excuse is... :hmm:

All-in-all the Tory campaign, ruthless and back-stabby as it was, comes out as efficient and creditable compared to the clownish efforts of UKIP and Labour.
"Come grow old with me
The Best is yet to be
The last of life for which the first was made."

Brazen

The brands favoured by Leave and Remain voters. Brexiters are having Iceland ready meals with HP sauce in front of the ITV news, while Remainers are booking their Airbnb break while browsing the BBC website.

http://www.campaignlive.co.uk/article/top-10-brands-favoured-remainers-brexiters/1403991

Richard Hakluyt

Let me see now :

Leave brands 0/10

Remain brands 7/10

Works in my case.

mongers

Quote from: Richard Hakluyt on August 03, 2016, 08:00:00 AM
Let me see now :

Leave brands 0/10

Remain brands 7/10

Works in my case.

Leave brands 0/10

Remain brands 4/10

Similar for me, but not so pronounced? 

Maybe occasionally watching ITV News if it's the only one on gives me a 1/10 in the remain camp.

Though still not entirely sure about identifying with a brand, I just assumed it was using it.
"We have it in our power to begin the world over again"

Brazen

Leave brands 4/10

Remain brands 7/10

The survey says consume rather than trust or identify with, but I'd only count regularly and recently; hence I'm also discounting ITV News. The only ones I've never touched are The Health Lottery and Richmond Sausages, and I've browsed but never booked Airbnb.

garbon

Leave 1/10
Remain 10/10

:D
"I've never been quite sure what the point of a eunuch is, if truth be told. It seems to me they're only men with the useful bits cut off."
I drank because I wanted to drown my sorrows, but now the damned things have learned to swim.

Josquius

Quote from: Brazen on August 03, 2016, 07:53:34 AM
The brands favoured by Leave and Remain voters. Brexiters are having Iceland ready meals with HP sauce in front of the ITV news, while Remainers are booking their Airbnb break while browsing the BBC website.

http://www.campaignlive.co.uk/article/top-10-brands-favoured-remainers-brexiters/1403991

ITV :bleeding:

I'm 2x leave (not even sure what some are) and 7x remain.
██████
██████
██████