Why I hate fucking Catholic scumbags

[crazy canuck]

Fine. Perhaps you shouldn't bring up such examples then if, when called on their inconsistency or lack of logic, you hide behind secrecy?

Ok answer my general question earlier then - if two teenagers have sex with each other, and there is no evidence of rape, is any of them (both?) a sexual offender?

You continue to be daft.

You say to BB that you cant understand why one might be considered a sexual offender (which is incredibly stupid since anyone with an ounce of common sense can figure out a number of factual circumstances as to why that might be) and then you accuse BB of being inconsistent because he wont give you details he is obligated by law not to disclose.

I am now convinced that you got your law degree from a cracker jack box.

[dps]

I am now convinced that you got your law degree from a cracker jack box.

Doubtful.  You can probably get a better legal education from a Cracker Jack box than from a Polish law school.

[Barrister]

Fine. Perhaps you shouldn't bring up such examples then if, when called on their inconsistency or lack of logic, you hide behind secrecy?

Ok answer my general question earlier then - if two teenagers have sex with each other, and there is no evidence of rape, is any of them (both?) a sexual offender?

My example was only brought up to show that even when I could talk to experts about a real life situation and real life facts, they could only tell me "it depends".  This is complicated stuff.

As for your second paragraph - it depends.  First of all it's a mistake to take of evidence of rape - something can be a rape without there being any evidence.  Second it depends on specific circumstances. It could be a sex offence, or it could not be.

[Razgovory]

I think you should violate your professional ethics because Marty is throwing a fit.

[Martinus]

See, this is the kind of moronic mindset I am talking about here. How do you even determine which one is a "sex offender" if both of them are minors?

probably the same way you determine if a 14 year old committing another crime can be judged has an adult.

Are you really that retarded? you do not understand the difference between murder and a formal crime (i.e. sex with a minor) when both parties are minors?

When an adult kills another person it is clear who the victim and the perpetrator is. When a 14 yo kills someone then it is obvious who the victim and the perpetrator is.

When an adult has sex with a 14 yo without coercion being involved it is clear who the perpetrator and the victim is. When a 14 yo has sex with a 13 yo without coercion being involved who is the victim and the perpetrator? Both? None? Either?

[Josephus]

I love it when Poles call people from the civilized world "retarded."

[crazy canuck]

I love it when Poles call people from the civilized world "retarded."

More to the point, I love it when Marti thinks other people are retarded.

[MadImmortalMan]

I love it when Poles call people from the civilized world "retarded."

More to the point, I love it when Marti thinks other people are retarded.

He just doesn't like to have sex with scumbag Catholics.

[Barrister]

When an adult kills another person it is clear who the victim and the perpetrator is. When a 14 yo kills someone then it is obvious who the victim and the perpetrator is.

I wish I lived in Martinus-land where it is always "clear" who the victim and the perpetrator are.  It would save the numerous arguments, dicussions and debates we routinely have in trying to determine who should be charged in a given set of facts.

[Malthus]

Hey, gays aren't to blame for the Catholic Church's pedophilia scandal.

Jews are!

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article7095471.ece



We're a tricky lot, evidently. 

[Josephus]

Jews, they want to take the credit for everything.

[Syt]

Jews, they want to take the credit for everything.

Oh, they give credit, too, but only at extortionate rates.

[Alexandru H.]

[Malthus]

Jews, they want to take the credit for everything.

Oh, they give credit, too, but only at extortionate rates.

[viper37]

I am now convinced that you got your law degree from a cracker jack box.

if they ever hire a Polish lawyer at your firm, be afraid.  Be very afraid.