Most overrated WW2 commander

[Zoupa]

Well, I tried to have at least one from every major combatant. Though I couldn't find any Italian to put there.

Canada?

I think you missed this word.  There wasn't a Slovak commander on the list either.

What Raz said.

Sure. I guess 20% of D-Day means nothing.

[Threviel]

Well, I tried to have at least one from every major combatant. Though I couldn't find any Italian to put there.

Canada?

I think you missed this word.  There wasn't a Slovak commander on the list either.

What Raz said.

Sure. I guess 20% of D-Day means nothing.

No, not in the grand scheme of things. Sure, the canucks did good in the war, large escort fleet and an army in the western front. But what commander precisely should I have added?

[Barrister]

Well, I tried to have at least one from every major combatant. Though I couldn't find any Italian to put there.

Canada?

I think you missed this word.  There wasn't a Slovak commander on the list either.

What Raz said.

Sure. I guess 20% of D-Day means nothing.

No, not in the grand scheme of things. Sure, the canucks did good in the war, large escort fleet and an army in the western front. But what commander precisely should I have added?

Harry Crerar.

[Threviel]

Well, I tried to have at least one from every major combatant. Though I couldn't find any Italian to put there.

Canada?

I think you missed this word.  There wasn't a Slovak commander on the list either.

What Raz said.

Sure. I guess 20% of D-Day means nothing.

No, not in the grand scheme of things. Sure, the canucks did good in the war, large escort fleet and an army in the western front. But what commander precisely should I have added?

Harry Crerar.

Never heard of him, why does he fit in amongst the commanders above?

[Eddie Teach]

Hard to be overrated when people don't know who you are.

[Barrister]

Hey - you don't have to list generals from every combatant.

But if you're going to list fucking yugoslavs, and you claim to list combatants from each major power, you should list a Canadian.  And Gen. Crerar was the most senior Canadian commander during WWII.  And his Canadian 1st Army did liberate Holland.

[Richard Hakluyt]

Maybe you should start a most underrated poll. I think a lot of the Canadian war effort is subsumed within the British war effort by non-Canadians, which is a pity. Or you could hire the PR men that the Aussies use 

[Martinus]

Hard to be overrated when people don't know who you are.

LOL no kidding. 

[Threviel]

Hey - you don't have to list generals from every combatant.

But if you're going to list fucking yugoslavs, and you claim to list combatants from each major power, you should list a Canadian.  And Gen. Crerar was the most senior Canadian commander during WWII.  And his Canadian 1st Army did liberate Holland.

My ambition was to list generals from the major powers meaning: Germany, Italy, Soviet Union, China, Japan, US, GB. Besides that I wanted prominent and famous commanders. I of course couldn't find any overrated italian commander so that's a fail, but whatever.

Some dude that commanded an army on the western front isn't prominent enough. If that were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals.

[Viking]

Hey - you don't have to list generals from every combatant.

But if you're going to list fucking yugoslavs, and you claim to list combatants from each major power, you should list a Canadian.  And Gen. Crerar was the most senior Canadian commander during WWII.  And his Canadian 1st Army did liberate Holland.

My ambition was to list generals from the major powers meaning: Germany, Italy, Soviet Union, China, Japan, US, GB. Besides that I wanted prominent and famous commanders. I of course couldn't find any overrated italian commander so that's a fail, but whatever.

Some dude that commanded an army on the western front isn't prominent enough. If that were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals.

Yes, many Soviet Armies on the Western Front. Too many to count. 

[The Brain]

lol Canadians

[Threviel]

Hey - you don't have to list generals from every combatant.

But if you're going to list fucking yugoslavs, and you claim to list combatants from each major power, you should list a Canadian.  And Gen. Crerar was the most senior Canadian commander during WWII.  And his Canadian 1st Army did liberate Holland.

My ambition was to list generals from the major powers meaning: Germany, Italy, Soviet Union, China, Japan, US, GB. Besides that I wanted prominent and famous commanders. I of course couldn't find any overrated italian commander so that's a fail, but whatever.

Some dude that commanded an army on the western front isn't prominent enough. If that were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals.

Yes, many Soviet Armies on the Western Front. Too many to count. 

If army command were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals. Better?

[Viking]

If army command were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals. Better?

Much better, but please don't start thinking that a Red Army Division is to be counted as a full division.

[Threviel]

If army command were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals. Better?

Much better, but please don't start thinking that a Red Army Division is to be counted as a full division.

FFS . If army, army group or front (where applicable) command were enough the list would be full of german and soviet generals. Better?

[Grey Fox]

lol Canadians

Next time we'll stay on the side line. I hope you enjoy speaking Chino-Russian.