Israel-Hamas War 2023

[crazy canuck]

I guess my issue with calling Israel a Settler-Colonialist state that is out to exterminate indigenous people is the absurdity of insisting Jews are not indigenous to Palestine and the fact that a huge proportion of the population come from Iraq, Iran, Yemen, Egypt, and North Africa etc. and the extensive similarities between Israeli and Arab culture.

That is just radically different than something like United State or Australia.

Hence why I tend to view it as an old world ethnic conflict. Sure you do have large numbers of Jews from Europe moving into a non-European area so it has that in common, but that ignores so many other issues. And Israel seem pretty integrated into the area with their corrupt politicians, religious fanaticism, and cynicism.

Yeah, I think it would be a more useful to analyze what is happening in Israel from the perspective of Netanyahu holding on to power.

[Razgovory]

The article in the Atlantic is on par with normal articles in the Atlantic.  The quote you suggest was made up was in fact real and I found the source.  While he isn't a doctor of cultural studies like Olympic superstar Raygun, I think he's up to the task of writing a book on this topic.  It isn't particle physics.  And he has written a biography of Disraeli

[The Minsky Moment]

[The quote is from an academic paper https://eprints.lancs.ac.uk/id/eprint/160342/ 

That journal has an impact factor of 0.956, i.e. the average article is cited less than one time in the following two years.  To give a sense how low that is, a journal with a similar IF is the Review of Agricultural and Applied Economics of the Faculty of Economics and Management, Slovak Agricultural University in Nitra.  No offense to the agricultural economists of Slovakia, but I think we can assume their work isn't making massive ripples across the academic world.

Playing the game of find the wacky academic research paper is shooting fish in a barrel.  At least Alan Sokol did it with more panache and fun.

[viper37]

guess my issue with calling Israel a Settler-Colonialist state that is out to exterminate indigenous people is the absurdity of insisting Jews are not indigenous to Palestine and the fact that a huge proportion of the population come from Iraq, Iran, Yemen, Egypt, and North Africa etc. and the extensive similarities between Israeli and Arab culture.

The main problem is that you have people like Raz and OvB insisting Palestinians have no grounds to claim the lands they live on as their own.

But at the same time, they claim an ancestral tie to the land to all of the Jewish populations, no matter where they came from.

There is this absurdity here.

But we're always rehashing the same points.