The Most Agreeable Posters

[The Minsky Moment]

What I'm curious about is which posters do you think are most likely to change their position when faced with a reasonable argument or new evidence?

If you see something that looks like a reasonable argument, it probably isn't.  Becuase after all, this is the internet, and therefore the Bayesian prior probability of actually seeing a reasonable argument is vanishingly small.

If presented with new evidence, one should of course reconsider one's views.  But then again, if new evidence is coming in, shouldn't one say it appears the evidence is in flux and thus hold to one's position until all the facts are in?

[Admiral Yi]

Agreed.

Poser. 

[Martinus]

I think we should have an argument over the meaning of the word "agreeable". It's the Languish way.

[The Brain]

This thread is turning us all to gays and yes-men.

[Malthus]

I think we should have an argument over the meaning of the word "agreeable". It's the Languish way.

I agree.

Oh wait, I don't.

[Malthus]

Actually, the Languish way would be for the winner of the "Agreeable" contest to engage, the very same day, in a no-holds-barred knock-down argument that causes at least two other posters to ragequit. 

[mongers]

All this agreement sickens me. 

[DGuller]

Agreed.

Poser. 

Agreed.

[DGuller]

All this agreement sickens me. 

Agreed.

[Eddie Teach]

Cal would be a good choice, but I don't think he really participates in arguments much anymore.

Guller is agreeable in the sense that he's a good sport when made fun of. HVC too. Not the thread question, but thought I'd put that out there anyway.

Valmy maybe, though I've found him pretty tenacious at times. Perhaps "least stubborn" is more apt than "most agreeable". 

[lustindarkness]

I agree with you all.

[Ed Anger]

I hate you all.

[Tamas]

I am the most agreeable here and there is no way you can convince me otherwise.

[The Minsky Moment]

I am the most agreeable here and there is no way you can convince me otherwise.

More Pest than Bud(dh)a.

[DGuller]

I am the most agreeable here and there is no way you can convince me otherwise.

More Pest than Bud(dh)a.