The twenty best war movies, according to the Torygraph

[Admiral Yi]

From Here to Eternity dies for lack of interest, for real this time.

I nominate Breaker Morant vs. Ice-Cold in Alex.

[dps]

From Here to Eternity dies for lack of interest, for real this time.

I nominate Breaker Morant vs. Ice-Cold in Alex.

Breaker Morant

[Kleves]

Breaker.

[CountDeMoney]

As much as I love Breaker Morant, come on now, people.  We're talking war flicks, not courtroom dramas originally based on two act plays.

What the fuck is next, A Few Good Men?

[Admiral Yi]

As much as I love Breaker Morant, come on now, people.  We're talking war flicks, not courtroom dramas originally based on two act plays.

What the fuck is next, A Few Good Men?

A Few Good Men didn't take place during war.

Listen, why don't you post a list of the three movies ever made which qualify as honest-to-goodness war movies, then we can vote on the twenty that we like the most.

[CountDeMoney]

As much as I love Breaker Morant, come on now, people.  We're talking war flicks, not courtroom dramas originally based on two act plays.

What the fuck is next, A Few Good Men?

A Few Good Men didn't take place during war.

Listen, why don't you post a list of the three movies ever made which qualify as honest-to-goodness war movies, then we can vote on the twenty that we like the most.

Fine, then.  Casablanca.  Had a war in it.  Douche.

[Admiral Yi]

Fine, then.  Casablanca.  Had a war in it.  Douche.

Don't get all pissy just cuz I called after you went all in Teddy KGB.

[Kleves]

What the fuck is next, A Few Good Men?

Paths of Glory. 

[Tamas]

Have we covered Der Untergang yet? If Lawrence is a war movie, the Untergang is three war movies, and it is simply awesome

[CountDeMoney]

Have we covered Der Untergang yet? If Lawrence is a war movie, the Untergang is three war movies, and it is simply awesome

Sell your Eastern Euromutt Nazifanboism elsewhere, we're all stocked up here.

[Tamas]

It is the best anti-nazi flick ever, dude.

[Berkut]

Breaker Morant is not a war movie.

[Warspite]

Is The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp a war movie?

[grumbler]

Dudes, the "is it a war flick" question gets answered by the voting.  If you think flick A isn't a war flick, vote for flick B.  All this emo "Waaahh, you nominated a movie that isn't a war movie, if X is a war flick than so is Titanic!" shit gets old fast.

I agree that BM is a great flick but not a war flick, so vote for Ice Cold.

[Berkut]

I don't think it has gotten old yet.

I vote for Alex, on the assumption that even though I haven't seen it, it is actually a war movie.

And Morant, you know, isn't. A war movie, that is. Like Titanic.