What is YOUR favorite Quentin Tarantino film?

[Ideologue]

So, choose.  It's a free country.

To prove it, I chose Death Proof.

I realize that I often have contrary opinions, but I don't think of myself as some kind of Armond White-type asshole, throwing crullers at Steve McQueen's forehead during a New York Film Critics presentation.  I just really love Death Proof's style, love Kurt Russell (and Rose McGowan, and Rosario Dawson, and Tracie Thom, and Zoe Bell), and I think anyone has to consider it one of the most impressive pieces of stunt work and stunt driving ever filmed.  The only real contender for those titles that I've ever seen is the original Gone In 60 Seconds, and no one is riding on the hood of that Mustang; and of course that famous chase is not embedded in a horror/action diptych with fun acting turns, either.  (In fact, it's barely a movie, but I digress.)

TL; DR.  Yes, really.  So what if Pulp Fiction is "about" something?  Death Proof is about Zoe Bell riding on top of a fucking car.

Ranked:

1)Death Proof (A+)
2)Kill Bill, vol. 1/Kill Bill, vol. 2 (A+)
3)Django Unchained (A+)
4)Pulp Fiction (A+)
5)Reservoir Dogs (A)
6)Four Rooms (A) (to get into the nitty-gritty: C+, B+, A+, A+ for each individual short film, respectively)
7)Jackie Brown (B+)
8)Inglorious Basterds (B+)

[Ideologue]

Fuck, I forgot to include Jackie Brown.  Can I edit that in, or not, or what?

[alfred russel]

I have seen 3 of the movies. Pulp Fiction, Inglorious Basterds, and Django.

All were good, but Pulp Fiction was iconic. People are quoting that movie and talking about the scenes more today than the other two much more recent films. Also, the soundtrack was outstanding.

[The Brain]

Pulp Fiction.

[katmai]

Fuck, I forgot to include Jackie Brown.  Can I edit that in, or not, or what?

Edited in for you by your overlairds.

[Eddie Teach]

Pulp Fiction A+
Kill Bill A
Reservoir Dogs A-
Jackie Brown B+
Inglourious Basterds B+
Death Proof C+
Django Unchained C

(but graded on a scale where Fs aren't reserved for random movies that piss me off)

[Syt]

I like Pulp Fiction best, but I think technically Django Unchained is his best movie. But I like all his movies. I think Death Proof is underrated, but not an A+.

[katmai]

Picked Pulp, but haven't seen Django or Death Proof yet.

[Syt]

If I were to rank the movies he directed (by personal preference, not artistic merit):

- Pulp Fiction
- Django Unchained
- Reservoir Dogs
- Inglorious Basterds
- Kill Bill
- Death Proof
- Jackie Brown

That said, I really enjoy watching any of those movies, but for different things. He and Stanley Kubrick might be the only two directors where I can watch any film of theirs and have a good time.

[Admiral Yi]

Pulp Fiction:  A+
Reservoir Dogs: C+ I really don't get this movies appeal.  They call each other funny names and the ratty looking English actor moans for an hour.
Inglories Bistdurds: B
Kill Bill uno y dos: B-
Jackie Brown: B
Death Proof: C+

[celedhring]

Pulp Fiction is one of the most influential movies of its time, and I also is pretty damn good on its own. Easily gets my vote. Death Proof had some fun stuff in it, it's a weird crossover of American grindhouse films with 60s French cinema but ultimately just doesn't feel fullfilling as a film, imho.

My personal rank would be:

- Pulp Fiction
- Reservoir Dogs
- Jackie Brown
- Kill Bill
- Django
- Unglorious Basterds
- Death Proof
- Four Rooms (his episode is easily the best of that mess though)

[Syt]

When I watched Pulp Fiction for the first time in 1998 or so, I rewound the tape immediately after the end credits and watched it again. Only movie that ever made me do that.

[celedhring]

I started film school in 1996, just a couple years after it came out, and 90% of the students were doing Pulp Fiction ripoffs as their student films. Jump 10 years later, to my first day of postgrad at Columbia; what's the lecture about? Pulp Fiction. It really was that important.

[Josquius]

Pulp Fiction
My ranking:

1)Pulp Fiction (A*)
2)Kill Bill (A+)
3)Reservoir Dogs (A+)
4)Django Unchained (A)
5)Inglorious Basterds (A)
6)Jackie Brown (D)
7)Death Proof (D)
X) Four rooms (Never even heard of it)

Jackie Brown and Death Proof I just didn't like at all. I can hardly remember anything about them. They were dull and forgettable. Not even so-so. His other films are awesome.

[Admiral Yi]

Oh yeah, saw From Dusk to Dawn as well.

C