Who's the manliest Star Trek Captain?

[Syt]

Speaking of nerdiness.

Jim Kirk:


Jean-Luc Picard:


Benjamin Sisko:


Kathryn Janeway:


Jonathan Archer:




Personally, I think it's a toss up between Kirk and Sisko. Kirk wrestled barehandedly with the Gorn, Sisko brawled with the Jem'Hadar. Kirk was getting crazy tail while Sisko is just all kinds of badass with a serious temper. Sisko before Kirk by a hair's breadth.

Picard is the refined gentleman and gets third place.

Janeway is all kinds of crazy, killing and bullying indiscriminately one day, being the understanding Samaritan the next. Props for going back in time to kick the Borg in the bionic nads. Forth place.

Archer ... well, he's Archer. And watches water polo.

[Grey Fox]

Kirk's picture is block for me at work.

New kirk or Old Kirk?

[Syt]

New kirk or Old Kirk?

Old series and first ten movies.

Not the Abrams timeline.

[dps]

Kirk's picture is block for me at work.

New kirk or Old Kirk?

I'm just getting the red X at home, as well.

There is no new Kirk.

[Eddie Teach]

So tempted to vote for Janeway. 

Ended up voting for Kirk(on assumption he meant Shatner, didn't see pic either).

[Syt]

Pic hopefully fixed.

[dps]

I see it now, at least.

[Grey Fox]

I'm voting Picard. Dude's the arbitor of the Klingon Empire.

[The Brain]

Picard is more manly than Kirk (and therefore all other captains). His bald head indicates high levels of testosterone.

[Solmyr]

No Captain Sulu?

[grumbler]

Picard by a mile:  he doesn't need the pretend-manliness that Kirk engages in, and he is just leaves Sisko in the dirt.

1.  Picard
2.  Sisko
3.  Janeway
4.  Kirk
5.  Archer

[Legbiter]

Picard headbutts the competition with his shiny noggin.

[crazy canuck]

Picard is the obvious choice.  Janeway does a good Picard imitation but she is no Picard.  Sisko is tainted with being a religious icon.  Kirk is, like Marti, trying too hard.  Archer?  Who is this Archer?

[Zanza2]

Kirk. Because unlike CC I don't think he is trying, he is just that awesome.

[Slargos]

Janeway, merely to be contrarian.

But honestly? Kirk. No doubt about it.