Top PC game of all time?

[Galrion]

Xcom.  I wholeheartedly agree.  http://pc.ign.com/articles/101/1011624p1.html

[Jaron]

Reeks of nostalgia.

[Josephus]

I must have been stoned in 1994, cause I don't even remember that game! The rest of them I remember fondly, except for the Sims stuff that I never played.

I played Diablo probably every day for six months.

I'm surprised that none of the games in the "Age of Empires" made it.

[DGuller]

I really loved Jagged Alliance games, and XCOM was billed as a better and more popular game of that genre.  I pirated it to see what all the buzz was about, and was dumbfounded.

[Eddie Teach]

I've only played 5 of those.

[Caliga]

I've played nearly every game on there, and I did really like X-COM, but I dunno about "greatest game of all time".

[jimmy olsen]

Half life is definitely my number 1.

[Sophie Scholl]

Disagree a lot with the list, but that's me.  I only played probably half of the games listed though.

[Neil]

Half life is definitely my number 1.

You're too young to remember what good games were like.

[CountDeMoney]

5) Battlefield 1942

Fuck yeah.

[CountDeMoney]

Half life is definitely my number 1.

You're too young to remember what good games were like.

LucasArt's Secret Weapons of the Luftwaffe or MicroProse's M1 Tank Platoon FTW.

[HisMajestyBOB]

Haven't played a lot of them, or I've just played them a little bit.
On my personal list, I'd substitute Angband for Diablo (they're basically the same I believe, except Diablo has graphics), the Marathon trilogy for Quake/Doom/etc.

C&C, SimCity, Mechwarrior 2... the list brings back some good memories.

I'll have to actually give X-Com a spin. I have it but haven't tried playing it yet.

[Fate]

Starcraft ranked lower than vanilla C&C? Are you kidding me?

[Barrister]

Only 2 games from earlier than 1990?

[Jaron]

PC games were pretty crappy that early on. I hardly think a game like Space Invaders deserves to be on the best games ever list.