If You were from Westeros or Essos

[Eddie Teach]

For our dedicated atheists, which god would you pretend to worship?

[Valmy]

Wait am I from Westeros or Essos in this scenario?

[Eddie Teach]

You are a world-wise scholar familiar with all the faiths and capable of picking the one you like the best.

[Grey Fox]

R'hllor because his Magic is real.

[Valmy]

R'hllor because his Magic is real.

Yeah I was thinking the same thing. Of course we cannot confirm or deny the magic of the others being false yet.

[Solmyr]

Clearly the Many-Faced God, because he's also all the other gods.

[Admiral Yi]

R'hllor because his Magic is real.

The Many Faced God has some tricks too, and isn't an asshole like R'hllor.

[The Minsky Moment]

R'hllor because his Magic is real.

And yet his followers are not advanced enough to grasp the proper use of vowels.
Pass.

[Grey Fox]

Atleast he has an actual name.

[Barrister]

The Great Shepherd sounds rather Christ-like, so I'll go with Him. 

[The Minsky Moment]

Atleast he has an actual name.

Not a selling point that a god so easily gives out his name to anyone, like some sort of divine traveling salesman.

[crazy canuck]

Atleast he has an actual name.

Not a selling point that a god so easily gives out his name to anyone, like some sort of divine traveling salesman.

[Crazy_Ivan80]

The Great Shepherd sounds rather Christ-like, so I'll go with Him. 

you only get a green, red and blue option though...

oh wait, wrong shepard.

[crazy canuck]

For me its a toss up between the Many Faced God and the Old Gods.  Both had some power before the dragons were reborn.  The God of Light needs the Dragons so is inferior.  I chose the Many Faced God just to tell him, not today.

[Martinus]

Given that the Seven turn out to be pretty homophobic, I'd say the Many Faced God.