http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2009/07/drm-for-news-inside-the-aps-plan-to-wrap-its-content.ars (http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2009/07/drm-for-news-inside-the-aps-plan-to-wrap-its-content.ars)
Content not posted in case the DRM Police show up and break vM's legs.
Quote from: Darth Wagtaros on July 28, 2009, 06:03:36 PM
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2009/07/drm-for-news-inside-the-aps-plan-to-wrap-its-content.ars (http://%20%20the%20associated%20press%20last%20week%20rolled%20out%20its%20brave%20new%20plan%20to%20%22apply%20protective%20format%20to%20news.%22%20the%20ap%27s%20news%20registry%20will%20%22tag%20and%20track%20all%20ap%20content%20online%20to%20assure%20compliance%20with%20terms%20of%20use,%22%20and%20it%20will%20provide%20a%20%22platform%20for%20protect,%20point,%20and%20pay.%22%20that%27s%20a%20lot%20of%20%22p%22-prefaced%20jargon,%20but%20it%20boils%20down%20to%20a%20sort%20of%20drm%20for%20news%c3%a2%c2%80%c2%94%22enforcement,%22%20in%20ap-speak.%20%20but%20how%20could%20that%20possibly%20work?%20It%20was%20good%20enough%20for%20music...%20%20Turns%20out%20that%20it%20won%27t,%20not%20really,%20not%20if%20the%20goal%20is%20to%20exercise%20control%20over%20AP%20content%20by%20those%20not%20voluntarily%20disposed%20to%20play%20by%20the%20AP%27s%20rules.%20First,%20let%27s%20try%20to%20make%20sense%20of%20what%27s%20being%20proposed.%20According%20to%20the%20AP%27s%20announcement,%20the%20news%20registry%20it%20plans%20to%20set%20up%20relies%20on%20a%20new%20%22microformat,%22%20described%20thusly:%20%20%20%20%20%20The%20microformat%20will%20essentially%20encapsulate%20AP%20and%20member%20content%20in%20an%20informational%20%22wrapper%22%20that%20includes%20a%20digital%20permissions%20framework%20that%20lets%20publishers%20specify%20how%20their%20content%20is%20to%20be%20used%20online%20and%20which%20also%20supplies%20the%20critical%20information%20needed%20to%20track%20and%20monitor%20its%20usage.%20%20%20%20%20%20The%20registry%20also%20will%20enable%20content%20owners%20and%20publishers%20to%20more%20effectively%20manage%20and%20control%20digital%20use%20of%20their%20content,%20by%20providing%20detailed%20metrics%20on%20content%20consumption,%20payment%20services%20and%20enforcement%20support.%20It%20will%20support%20a%20variety%20of%20payment%20models,%20including%20pay%20walls.%20%20To%20make%20the%20system%20clear,%20the%20AP%20also%20released%20this%20not-in-any-way%20confusing%20chart%20of%20what%20it%20intends%20to%20do.%20AP-chart.jpg%20%20The%20%22wrappers%22%20and%20%22digital%20permissions%20frameworks%22%20that%20it%20hopes%20to%20implement%20sound%20like%20tough%20encryption,%20but%20they%20aren%27t.%20Instead,%20the%20AP%20is%20simply%20relying%20on%20a%20newly-developed%20microformat%20called%20hNews.%20It%27s%20a%20simple%20HTML-based%20tagging%20scheme%20for%20marking%20up%20news%20content%20and%20making%20headlines,%20author%20names,%20and%20permitted%20uses%20machine-readable%20and%20search-engine%20friendly.%20%28See%20an%20example.%29%20hNews%20is%20funded%20by%20major%20foundations,%20and%20all%20of%20its%20tools%20and%20specs%20will%20be%20released%20as%20open-source%20software.%20%20In%20what%20way%20does%20this%20scheme%20%22wrap%22%20and%20%22protect%22%20the%20news?%20It%20doesn%27t;%20it%20simply%20marks%20it%20up,%20and%20adding%20tags%20expressing%20a%20content%20creator%27s%20wishes%20on%20reuse%20has%20no%20bearing%20on%20someone%27s%20rights%20under%20US%20copyright%20law.%20What%20it%20does%20do%20is%20provide%20organizations%20that%20use%20hNews%20a%20way%20to%20release%20more%20rights%20than%20are%20granted%20under%20copyright%C3%A2%C2%80%C2%94in%20essence,%20a%20sort%20of%20%22Creative%20Commons%22%20news%20license.%20In%20fact,%20hNews%27%20%22rights%20field%22%20uses%20ccREL,%20the%20Creative%20Commons%20Rights%20Expression%20Language.%20%20The%20AP%27s%20news%20registry%20will%20use%20hNews%20to%20embed%20some%20kind%20of%20Web%20beacon%20in%20news%20content%20as%20well,%20making%20it%20possible%20to%20track%20some%20uses%20of%20the%20story%20across%20the%20Web.%20Users%20who%20simply%20copy%20and%20paste%20parts%20of%20the%20story,%20or%20those%20who%20retype%20bits%20of%20it%20to%20use%20as%20quotes,%20or%20those%20of%20simply%20strip%20out%20the%20tags%20will%20of%20course%20not%20end%20up%20being%20tracked.%20%20You%27ll%20be%20forgiven%20if%20you%20find%20it%20difficult%20to%20square%20the%20reality%20of%20hNews%20with%20the%20AP%27s%20pronouncements%20about%20it.%20Ed%20Felten,%20the%20eminent%20Princeton%20computer%20security%20researcher,%20couldn%27t%20figure%20it%20out,%20either.%20%20%22It%20was%20hard%20to%20make%20sense%20of%20this,%20so%20I%20went%20looking%20for%20more%20information,%22%20he%20wrote%20on%20his%20blog.%20%22AP%20posted%20a%20diagram%20of%20the%20system,%20which%20only%20adds%20to%20the%20confusion%C3%A2%C2%80%C2%94your%20satisfaction%20with%20the%20diagram%20will%20be%20inversely%20proportional%20to%20your%20knowledge%20of%20the%20technology...%20hNews%20is%20a%20handy%20way%20of%20annotating%20news%20stories%20with%20information%20about%20the%20author,%20dateline,%20and%20so%20on.%20But%20it%20doesn%27t%20%27encapsulate%27%20anything%20in%20a%20%27wrapper,%27%20nor%20does%20it%20do%20much%20of%20anything%20to%20facilitate%20metering,%20monitoring,%20or%20paywalls.%22%20%20The%20great%20difficulty%20in%20talking%20about%20the%20AP%27s%20year-long%20push%20to%20stop%20%22misappropriation%22%20of%20its%20content%20is%20that%20it%20has%20never%20been%20quite%20clear%20what%20behavior%20AP%20is%20trying%20to%20stop.%20It%27s%20not%20targeting%20Google,%20as%20it%20already%20has%20a%20deal%20in%20place%20with%20Google%20to%20provide%20full-text%20feeds%20of%20its%20news%20stories.%20It%20doesn%27t%20appear%20to%20be%20going%20after%20small-time%20bloggers%20or%20those%20who%20use%20quotes%20from%20AP%20stories%20in%20their%20work.%20%20But%20it%20has%20pursued%20a%20%22hot%20news%22%20case%20recently%20%28which%20was%20just%20settled%29,%20and%20the%20AP%20seems%20to%20be%20signaling%20its%20intentions%20to%20go%20after%20sites%20that%20profit%20from%20large-scale%20use%20of%20AP%20headlines%20without%20paying%20for%20them.%20How%20the%20news%20registry%20helps%20them%20do%20this%20remains%20unclear,%20since%20sites%20that%20don%27t%20do%20what%20AP%20wants%20are%20unlikely%20to%20include%20its%20Web%20beacons.%20%20Is%20AP%20going%20after%20sites%20that%20occasionally%20quote%20from%20its%20news%20stories%20%28using%20proper%20citation%20and%20links%29?%20Such%20a%20move%20seems%20bizarre%20on%20its%20face%C3%A2%C2%80%C2%94and%20the%20AP%20routinely%20cites%20sources%20of%20its%20own,%20including%20Ars%20Technica%C3%A2%C2%80%C2%94but%20it%27s%20not%20out%20of%20the%20question.%20When%20paidContent%27s%20Staci%20D.%20Kramer%20put%20the%20question%20recently%20to%20AP%20Chairman%20Dean%20Singleton,%20the%20response%20was%20slightly%20creepy.%20%20%22I%20was%20a%20little%20taken%20aback%20when%20I%20asked%20Singleton%20what%20would%20happen%20to%20sites%20like%20ours:%20%27I%27ll%20leave%20that%20to%20the%20rules%20of%20engagement%20that%20we%27ll%20be%20developing%27%20in%20coming%20weeks.%20Not%20%27we%27re%20not%20after%20sites%20like%20yours%27%20or%20%27we%27re%20looking%20at%20flagrant%20violators.%27%20And%20no%20sign%20at%20all%20that%20AP%20will%20be%20reaching%20out%20beyond%20its%20members%20for%20input.%22%20%20And%20yet,%20when%20we%20spoke%20to%20AP%20back%20in%20June,%20AP%20news%20editor%20Ted%20Bridis%20seemed%20much%20more%20sure%20of%20the%20answer.%20%20%20%20%20%20OK,%20we%20said.%20How%20will%20you%20define%20%22wholesale%20theft?%22%20If%20somebody%20publishes%20a%20paragraph%20of%20AP%20copy%20with%20a%20link%20to%20the%20AP%20story,%20will%20that%20be%20theft?%20%20%20%20%20%20%22Not%20at%20all,%22%20Bridis%20replied.%20%22I%20don%27t%20think%20AP%20would%20have%20any%20problem%20with%20that.%22%20We%20didn%27t%20want%20to%20give%20the%20impression%20that%20we%20were%20bargaining,%20but%20we%20pressed%20on%20as%20to%20exactly%20how%20one%20would%20disturb%20AP%27s%20comfort%20zone.%20Was%20this%20about%20not%20posting%20links?%20%20%20%20%20%20No,%20Bridis%20replied.%20%22What%20I%27m%20talking%20about,%20and%20what%20has%20really%20riled%20up%20our%20internal%20copyright%20folks,%20are%20the%20bloggers%20who%20take,%20just%20paste%20an%20entire%20800%20word%20story%20into%20their%20blog.%20They%20don%27t%20even%20comment%20on%20it.%20And%20it%20happens%20way%20more%20than%20most%20people%20realize.%22%20%20%20But%20neither%20hNews%20nor%20the%20news%20registry%20will%20do%20anything%20to%20stop%20bloggers%20copying%20text%20off%20a%20webpage,%20and%20they%20certainly%20won%27t%20stop%20people%20from%20doing%20marginal%20%22rewrites%22%20of%20AP%27s%20work%20and%20passing%20it%20off%20as%20original%20writeups.%20%20So%20this%20all%20might%20be%20about%20wholesale%20infringement,%20or%20it%20might%20be%20about%20the%20%22hot%20news%22%20contained%20in%20AP%20headlines%20and%20ledes,%20or%20it%20might%20be%20both.%20But%20the%20one%20thing%20it%20isn%27t%20is%20%22clear%22%C3%A2%C2%80%C2%94the%20journalist%27s%20cardinal%20sin.%20%20hNews%20looks%20like%20a%20nice%20way%20to%20mark%20up%20news,%20to%20make%20it%20visible%20to%20search%20engines,%20and%20to%20provide%20useful%20metadata%20for%20those%20who%20want%20to%20do%20interesting%20things%20with%20the%20content.%20But%20what%20it%20has%20to%20do%20with%20%22wrappers,%22%20%22enforcement,%22%20and%20%22protection%22%20is%20unclear.%20Reading%20the%20AP%20announcement%20and%20the%20graphic%20that%20accompanied%20it,%20one%20is%20struck%20by%20the%20thought%20that%20perhaps%20the%20AP%20has%20been%20snookered%20into%20believing%20that%20it%27s%20getting%20%22DRM%20for%20news,%22%20when%20in%20reality%20it%27s%20simply%20using%20an%20open-source%20news%20metadata%20markup%20language%20with%20Creative%20Commons%20rights%20expression.%20%20Certainly,%20there%27s%20a%20pretty%20large%20contingent%20of%20writers%20in%20the%20blogosphere%20who%20think%20the%20AP%20is%20simply%20misguided,%20out%20of%20touch,%20or%20simply%20stupid.%20It%27s%20the%20sort%20of%20attitude%20that%20leads%20to%20mocking%20graphics%20which%20may%20be%20uncharitable,%20but%20it%20is%20quite%20obvious%20that%20hNews%20and%20a%20registry%20aren%27t%20going%20to%20save%20the%20traditional%20news%20industry%20without%20some%20significant%20other%20changes.%20%20Down%20the%20road,%20of%20course,%20the%20AP%20might%20go%20to%20Congress%20and%20ask%20that%20whatever%20tracking%20and%20rights%20system%20it%20settles%20on%20be%20given%20the%20force%20of%20law.%20It%27s%20not%20as%20crazy%20as%20it%20sounds;%20European%20publishers%20already%20hope%20to%20get%20a%20law%20enforcing%20the%20Automated%20Content%20Access%20Protocol.%20%20%22We%20need%20search%20engines%20to%20recognize%20ACAP%20as%20a%20step%20towards%20acknowledging%20that%20content%20providers%20have%20the%20right%20to%20decide%20what%20happens%20to%20their%20content%20and%20on%20what%20terms,%22%20said%20the%20Chairman%20of%20ACAP,%20Gavin%20O%27Reilly,%20recently.%20%22The%20European%20Commission%20and%20other%20legislators%20call%20on%20our%20industry%20constantly%20to%20come%20up%20with%20solutions%C3%A2%C2%80%C2%94here%20we%20have%20one%20and%20we%20call%20upon%20the%20regulators%20to%20back%20it%20up.%22)
Content not posted in case the DRM Police show up and break vM's legs.
What the hell did you do to that link son?
Fixed. Now read it.
Quote from: Darth Wagtaros on July 28, 2009, 06:40:13 PM
Fixed. Now read it.
Doesn't seem to work, and I don't seem to be in the demographic that they're targeting either.
Pathetic.
Either AP's contracting a modified version of the platform or they're about to get served, big-time.