Poll
Question:
Who Contributed Most to Humanity in the 18th and 19th Centuries?
Option 1: Engineers
votes: 23
Option 2: Lawyers
votes: 0
Option 3: Broadly Similar
votes: 1
Option 4: Don't Know
votes: 1
Prompted by Sav and Ide's comments in another thread, I'd like to know quite group contributed most to humanity during the 18th and 19th centuries ?
And if your using examples in your argument then the individual you champion, must have practised as least one quarter of their career during that century.
I didn't broaden it out to include the 20th century for obvious reasons. :ph34r:
I am about to interview for Engineering internships in a couple days so...obviously being an Engineer is the highest profession to which a human being could aspire.
Engineers by a factor of one thousand.
Thing is, back is those days, especially the earlier parts, a man might well be both. And a linguist, and a businessman, and a historian, and, well, you get the idea.
Has a lawyer ever contributed to humanity in a positive way?
I think I mentioned before that historically left revolutions have drawn disproportionate support from lawyers and right revolutions (including islamists) have drawn disproportionate support from engineers.
Quote from: Admiral Yi on September 15, 2013, 05:09:44 PM
I think I mentioned before that historically left revolutions have drawn disproportionate support from lawyers and right revolutions (including islamists) have drawn disproportionate support from engineers.
I don't recall you mentioning this before.
I'm only going to say this once: good question, Mongers! :P
I had a hard time deciding, and was astonished to see the results when I did decide. I counted the Philosphs as lawyers, though, so for me it was Enlightenment versus Industrial Revolution. Maybe others did not see it that way, though.
It's really hard to compare the two. Lawyers are important to civil societies, since well-entrenched rule of law seems to be what keeps societies from sliding into autocracies. On the other hand, it's hard to imagine modern societies without all the technological innovations that have been made in the rather unusual last couple of centuries.