Hassidic modesty mafia terrorizes Brooklyn

[The Larch]

How's that for sensationalistic headlines? Good enough for the Post?

Modesty in Ultra-Orthodox Brooklyn Is Enforced by Secret Squads


Faceless heads model on Lee Avenue in Brooklyn, where women's clothing stores have been warned not to use mannequins.

The Brooklyn shopkeeper was already home for the night when her phone rang: a man who said he was from a neighborhood "modesty committee" was concerned that the mannequins in her store's window, used to display women's clothing, might inadvertently arouse passing men and boys.

"The man said, 'Do the neighborhood a favor and take it out of the window,' " the store's manager recalled. " 'We're trying to safeguard our community.' "

In many neighborhoods, a store owner might shrug off such a call. But on Lee Avenue, the commercial spine of Hasidic Williamsburg, the warning carried an implied threat — comply with community standards or be shunned. It is a potent threat in a neighborhood where shadowy, sometimes self-appointed modesty squads use social and economic leverage to enforce conformity.

The owner wrestled with the request for a day or two, but decided to follow it. "We can sell it without mannequins, so we might as well do what the public wants," the owner told the manager, who asked not to be identified because of fear of reprisals for talking.

In the close-knit world of ultra-Orthodox Judaism, community members know the modesty rules as well as Wall Street bankers who show up for work in a Brooks Brothers suit. Women wear long skirts and long-sleeved, high-necked blouses on the street; men do not wear Bermuda shorts in summer. Schools prescribe the color and thickness of girls' stockings.

The rules are spoken and unspoken, enforced by social pressure but also, in ways that some find increasingly disturbing, by the modesty committees. Their power is evident in the fact that of the half dozen women's clothing stores along Lee Avenue, only one features mannequins, and those are relatively shapeless, fully clothed torsos.

The groups have long been a part of daily life in the ultra-Orthodox communities that dot Brooklyn and other corners of the Jewish world. But they sprang into public view with the trial of Nechemya Weberman, a prominent member of the Satmar Hasidim in Brooklyn, who last week was sentenced to 103 years in prison after being convicted of sexually abusing a young girl sent to him for counseling.

Mr. Weberman, an unlicensed therapist, testified during his trial that boys and girls — though not his accuser — were regularly referred to him by a Hasidic modesty committee concerned about what it viewed as inappropriate attire and behavior.

The details were startling: a witness for Mr. Weberman's defense, Baila Gluck, testified that masked men representing a modesty committee in the Hasidic village of Kiryas Joel, N.Y., 50 miles northwest of New York City, broke into her bedroom about seven years ago and confiscated her cellphone.

The Brooklyn district attorney, Charles J. Hynes, who prosecuted the Weberman case, has now received allegations that members of a modesty committee forced their way into a home in the borough, confiscating an iPad and computer equipment deemed inappropriate for Orthodox children, officials say. Allegations have also surfaced that a modesty committee threatened to publicly shame a married man who was having an affair unless he paid the members money for what they described as therapy.

"They operate like the Mafia," said Rabbi Allan Nadler, director of the Jewish studies program at Drew University in Madison, N.J.

Rabbi Nadler, who testified at Mr. Weberman's trial, said that modesty committees did not have addresses, stationery or business cards, and that few people seemed to know where their authority originated, though it was doubtful, he said, that they could continue operating without the tacit blessings of rabbinical leaders.

"They walk into a store and say it would be a shame if your window was broken or you lost your clientele," he said. "They might tell the father of a girl who wears a skirt that's too short and he's, say, a store owner: 'If you ever want to sell a pair of shoes, speak to your daughter.' "

In Israel, there have been similar concerns. Though no modesty committee was overtly involved, there has been anger over ultra-Orthodox zealots who spit on and insulted an 8-year-old girl for walking to school through their neighborhood in a dress they considered immodest.

In Brooklyn, Assemblyman Dov Hikind, who has represented the heavily Hasidic neighborhood of Borough Park for 30 years, said that he had never met a modesty committee member, but that "there are a lot of independent operators that believe they are protecting God and have to do this kind of stuff, and that's sickening and gives us all a black eye."

"If you want to advocate modesty," he added, "do your thing, but when you stuff it down my throat physically, that undermines us and hurts us."

Hasidic leaders contend that the modesty committees are nothing more than self-appointed individuals who, indignant at some perceived infraction, take matters into their own hands.

"These are individual people who decide to take on this crusade," said Rabbi David Niederman, who as president of the United Jewish Organization of Williamsburg is a sometime spokesman for the Satmar Hasidim. "You see posters telling people do this and do that. It does not represent an authorized body."

But many Hasidim say they have seen or heard how a shadowy group of men seeks to pressure parents to rein in children who wear dresses too short or stockings too thin, or who chat on cellphones with friends of the opposite sex. One family reported being harassed because the wife had stepped outdoors with a robelike housecoat rather than a long dress.

While many of the rules of conduct are announced on Yiddish broadsides posted on trees, lampposts and walls, residents of Hasidic neighborhoods say some store owners have received rough verbal warnings from a modesty committee to stop selling magazines that carry photographs considered too revealing, or articles that dispute the Satmar Hasidim's belief that Israel should not have existed until the Messiah's arrival.

The Central Rabbinical Congress of the United States and Canada, in addition to certifying foods as kosher and adjudicating matrimonial and commercial disputes, does at times remind the Satmar community of the community's modesty rules. It is made up of scores of rabbis, but it has an address — it is housed on the second floor of a Williamsburg row house — and it signs every decree it issues.

"We give out proclamations," said Rabbi Yitzchok Glick, its executive director. "We don't enforce. It's like people can decide to keep Shabbos or not. If someone wants to turn on the light on Shabbos, we cannot put him in jail for that."

But Hasidim interviewed said squads of enforcers did exist in wildcat form.

"There are quite a few men, especially in Williamsburg, who consider themselves Gut's polizei," said Yosef Rapaport, a Hasidic journalist, using the words for "God's police."

"It's somebody who is a busybody, and they're quite a few of them — zealots who take it upon themselves and they just enforce. They're considered crazy, but people don't want to confront them."

[The Larch]

If those guys get worked up by mannequins they should have a women's clothing shop operated by latinos opened in their neighbourhood. I bet their mannequins would be shaped like Sofía Vergara.

[garbon]

Well not so sensational if what Rabbi Nadler says is true.

[Valmy]

"They walk into a store and say it would be a shame if your window was broken or you lost your clientele," he said. "They might tell the father of a girl who wears a skirt that's too short and he's, say, a store owner: 'If you ever want to sell a pair of shoes, speak to your daughter.' "

Wow that does sound like organized crime.  Isn't this illegal?

[Malthus]

"They walk into a store and say it would be a shame if your window was broken or you lost your clientele," he said. "They might tell the father of a girl who wears a skirt that's too short and he's, say, a store owner: 'If you ever want to sell a pair of shoes, speak to your daughter.' "

Wow that does sound like organized crime.  Isn't this illegal?

Threatening to break windows is indeed illegal. Threatening to take one's custom elsewhere is not.

Highly obnoxious, though.

[Admiral Yi]

Threatening to take your business somewhere else is a God-given right.

[crazy canuck]

"They walk into a store and say it would be a shame if your window was broken or you lost your clientele," he said. "They might tell the father of a girl who wears a skirt that's too short and he's, say, a store owner: 'If you ever want to sell a pair of shoes, speak to your daughter.' "

Wow that does sound like organized crime.  Isn't this illegal?

Threatening to break windows is indeed illegal. Threatening to take one's custom elsewhere is not.

Highly obnoxious, though.

Reminds me of a prof I once had who earnestly explained to the class that although some organization to which he belonged called for the boycott of company X's products to protest something or other, he really really liked that company's brand of peanut butter and in the end he broke down a bought a jar.

[Neil]

They're the ultra-orthodox.  These people are the enemy of all mankind, just as all other fundamentalists are.

[Eddie Teach]

It would be a shame if Malthus's windows got broken.

[DGuller]

Fundamentalists are fundamentalists.  Film at 11.