WW2 Alt.Hist. Scenario

[mongers]

How would World War Two play out if the entire FDR presidency was replaced with donald trump and his cronies?

[Tonitrus]

President Fred Trump would be more plausible. 

[mongers]

President Fred Trump would be more plausible. 

 

For some reason I thought his father was an immigrant from German, but maybe that was me conflating his grandmother with Scots born mother?

I could certainly see trumpist America allying with Hitler in order to invade NE England and seize all of those beautiful coalmines. 

[crazy canuck]

How would World War Two play out if the entire FDR presidency was replaced with donald trump and his cronies?

HBO had a very good series on just that premise, the America firsters took over the United States and supported the Nazis

[Norgy]

"The Plot Against America" by Philip Roth?
It seems sort of plausible even, with anti-semites like father Coughlin stoking the race conflict, the Bund supporting Lindbergh/Trump and a slower pace on the fascist laws than the past, how many years have Trump been president now, 50? That sounds about right, at least I have aged that much.

I am not sure what would replace the Truth Social drops, but perhaps billboards?

[The Brain]

The US surrendering to Japan on the deck of the Nagato in October 1937.

[Crazy_Ivan80]

The US becomes the soft underbelly of the axis, making Mussolini look good.
Mexico joins the allies early, invades. The US splits and the regno del sud joins the allies ensuring that the US can still claim being part of the allied victory afterwards

 

[Josquius]

Canada nukes DC

[Crazy_Ivan80]

Canada nukes DC

Finish the 1812 effort

[grumbler]

(snip)
For some reason I thought his father was an immigrant from German, but maybe that was me conflating his grandmother with Scots born mother?

The reason you thought that is because Trump has repeatedly stated that to be the case. It's one of the weirder Trump lies because he has repeated it so often (at least four times). The birth certificate proves otherwise and has been shown on-air each time he lies about it. Is this senility, or just obvious lying for the sake of obvious lying?

[Sheilbh]

How would World War Two play out if the entire FDR presidency was replaced with donald trump and his cronies?

Honestly this sent me down a bit of a rabbit hole - because my immediate thought was that FDR was very important. And then that actually all the combatant leaders were really important.

And now I'm just wondering if WW2 is the last outpost of great man history and the extent to which any of them really mattered?

[grumbler]

Honestly this sent me down a bit of a rabbit hole - because my immediate thought was that FDR was very important. And then that actually all the combatant leaders were really important.

And now I'm just wondering if WW2 is the last outpost of great man history and the extent to which any of them really mattered?

I think that FDR's unique contribution was his persistence in insisting on aiding the UK before the US got involved in the war, despite considerable political pressure to do otherwise. I am not aware of any other politician with the stature and the willingness to violate both the US and international laws on neutral behavior in a cause that, in retrospect, was crucial to the outcome.

[crazy canuck]

"The Plot Against America" by Philip Roth?
It seems sort of plausible even, with anti-semites like father Coughlin stoking the race conflict, the Bund supporting Lindbergh/Trump and a slower pace on the fascist laws than the past, how many years have Trump been president now, 50? That sounds about right, at least I have aged that much.

I am not sure what would replace the Truth Social drops, but perhaps billboards?

That's the one