What are you listening to?

[CountDeMoney]

Waited until midnight for Alice In Chains' "The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here".  Ah, grunge.

[garbon]

Utada - Merry Christmas Mr. Lawrence - FYI

[fhdz]

You had to be there.

No, it's her voice. I like plenty of music from that same era, and earlier.

If helps if you were young when she first burst upon the scene, not be be forgotten. 

I was 3 when Wuthering Heights came out. My dad listened to Motown, not Kate Bush.

By your logic, no one who was born after about 1950 should be able to have an appreciation of the Beatles.

Which is of course incorrect.

[fhdz]

QotSA- I appear missing

[Ed Anger]

QotSA- I appear missing

Their new album fits my mood right now.

[The Brain]

Sabaton - The Lion From The North

[garbon]

Tori Amos - Flying Dutchman

[The Brain]

Sabaton - Ghost Division

[The Brain]

Sabaton - Uprising

Considering the band name and that they have several songs about Poles kicking ass I wonder why Mart isn't all over them.

[mongers]

You had to be there.

No, it's her voice. I like plenty of music from that same era, and earlier.

If helps if you were young when she first burst upon the scene, not be be forgotten. 

[/b]

I was 3 when Wuthering Heights came out. My dad listened to Motown, not Kate Bush.

By your logic, no one who was born after about 1950 should be able to have an appreciation of the Beatles.

Which is of course incorrect.

Wrong side of bed this morning? 

There does logic come into it ?

An opinion about music is just a view point and a matter of ones own tastes, not a foundation on which to build universal laws about music appreciation. 

But I suppose that is not the correct languish way of seeing things.


Your construction of a strawman out of the 2nd quoted passage is positively grumbleresque, you are to be congratulated. 

Did it not occur to you that the statement might just be an observation linked to that state of much popular British pop music in the mid to late 1970s.
The music she made and the way it was presented, was to many of us something refreshingly different and experimental, so one can't help but in part experience the music within the context of the times we first heard it.

Though please do extrapolate some new construct of my new comments too. 

[fhdz]

Having a broad spectrum of tastes, I just detest the "you're not old enough to appreciate x" argument; it smacks of elitism and furthermore is incorrect.

[mongers]

Having a broad spectrum of tastes, I just detest the "you're not old enough to appreciate x" argument; it smacks of elitism and furthermore is incorrect.

Though please do extrapolate some new construct of my new comments too. 

Congratulations you did it again.

Good job I wasn't making that argument or for that matter an argument, but again please do carry on. 

[fhdz]

You had to be there. 

If helps if you were young when she first burst upon the scene

My point was that whether I was there or not, I'd still very likely dislike her voice intensely.

[mongers]

You had to be there. 

If helps if you were young when she first burst upon the scene

My point was that whether I was there or not, I'd still very likely dislike her voice intensely.

How does this relate to your two subsequent 'constructs' ?

edit:
why am I being so polite ?

You choose to take an off the cuff comment about musical taste and extrapolate a strawman or two out of it, for whatever personal reason/mood you're currently in.  And then continue to labour the point, maybe I should just say go fuck yourself, Fadhiz, that is the languish way is it not, and possibly easier for you to understand ?   

[fhdz]

You had to be there. 

If helps if you were young when she first burst upon the scene

My point was that whether I was there or not, I'd still very likely dislike her voice intensely.

How does this relate to your two subsequent 'constructs' ?

Because whether or not I was old enough to "be there" has, I would think, very little to do with the reasons why I find Kate Bush singularly unappealing.